He is just cinchy. I heard that for years about Sarge, my 16-year-old bay Quarter Horse gelding. Then in the spring of 2024 I found a raw rub behind his left elbow after a four-hour ride in the Kickapoo Valley Reserve. It was not a saddle sore. It was a cinch rub from an old string cinch that had seen better days. I swapped to the Weaver Equine Felt Lined Smart Cinch in April 2024. I have used it about two and a half years, three rides a week from April through November. The rub healed in about three weeks of rest and has not come back.
I am not a trainer, vet, or saddle fitter. I am 61, I keep one horse on eleven acres outside Viroqua, Wisconsin, and I buy my own tack. This is for the rider who has a sensitive horse and is tired of guessing. A felt lined cinch is not a cure for bad saddle fit. It is one piece of the puzzle, and for Sarge it was the piece that stopped the rub. Measure your horse, check the saddle, and call a fitter or vet for anything more than a surface rub.
If your horse flinches when you reach for the cinch, start here
The felt liner on the Weaver Equine Smart Cinch gives a sensitive horse a softer surface than a worn string cinch. Check the listing, measure your horse, and rule out saddle fit before you blame the horse.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →The felt liner spreads contact instead of pinching one spot
A string cinch is a narrow line under the barrel. When a horse is sensitive, that line is where the trouble starts. The Weaver Equine Smart Cinch uses a 1/2 inch polyester felt liner under a poly webbing top. That gives the cinch a softer face against the hair and a cushion between the hardware and the horse. It is not a saddle fit cure. It is one less hard edge against a horse that already feels every edge.
It puts a buffer between the webbing and the coat
Sarge is wide through the barrel and he does not tolerate a rough cinch. The felt face on this cinch sits between the webbing and his coat, so the webbing is not what is rubbing him. I still check for grit every ride. A clean cinch is half the battle. But the felt gives me a surface I can brush off and inspect, instead of a frayed string that hides dirt.
A rub that had already started healed without a tack change every week
The rub behind Sarge's left elbow was small, maybe the size of a quarter, and raw at the edge. I did not ride him for about three weeks. I kept the area clean and dry, and I put the old string cinch in the barn sale pile. The Weaver Equine felt lined cinch went on when I started back. The hair grew in and the spot stayed quiet. That is the kind of result that makes you stop shopping around.
The weight is easy on older hands
The listing puts this cinch at 1.5 pounds. That is not a heavy piece of tack to lift, carry to the wash rack, or hang on a hook. My hands are not what they were at 40. A cinch that does not fight me when I saddle up is one I will actually take off and check. When a cinch is awkward, people leave it on the saddle and never look at the liner. This one is easy to handle.
Stainless hardware means one less rust stain on the horse
The listing says non-rust stainless steel hardware. I have had cheap cinch rings leave a brown streak on a pad after a wet ride. That is not a crisis, but it tells you what is happening at the ring. The hardware on the Weaver Equine cinch has stayed clean through two and a half years of Wisconsin humidity, trail dust, and the occasional creek crossing. I still wipe it dry. Stainless is not a license to store it wet.
The felt brushes out in a couple of minutes
My routine is simple. I take the cinch off, lay it on the tack room bench, and brush the felt with a stiff brush. Hair, grit, and dried sweat come off. Then it goes on a hook. I do not soak it and I do not put it in the washing machine. The felt liner on the Weaver Equine cinch has not balled up or separated. The webbing top still lies flat. That is two and a half years of regular trail use.
A nervous horse has less to object to
I am not a trainer. I am a woman with one horse and a small barn. But I have seen the difference between a cinch that feels like a rope and one that feels like a padded strap. A girthy horse still needs slow work and a saddle fit check. The felt liner just removes one sharp complaint. On Sarge, the ears stayed forward and the tail stayed quiet when I tightened this cinch. That is not a training method. It is a better surface.
No separate cover to bunch or shift
I have seen riders stack a fleece cover over a cinch to soften it. That can work, but a cover shifts, bunches, and holds grit if you do not watch it. The Weaver Equine cinch has the felt liner built in. There is no extra piece to straighten every time I saddle up. For a sensitive horse, fewer layers mean fewer places for a wrinkle to start. It also means I can see the whole contact surface when I check him after a ride.
It suits a wide barrel without a crank down contest
Sarge is 15.1 hands and about 1,100 pounds, and his withers are wide. I do not need to haul on the cinch to keep the saddle from rolling. I check the fit, tighten in stages, and walk him out before I get on. The felt lined cinch gives me a steady surface through that process. I still use a saddle with full Quarter Horse bars and I still check it. No cinch fixes a saddle that bridges or rocks. This one makes the part I can control less of a fight.
It is plain gear I can understand and maintain
There is nothing electronic, nothing that needs a battery, and nothing that needs a special wash. The cinch is felt, webbing, and stainless hardware. If the felt gets packed with mud, I brush it and let it dry. If the hardware looks dull, I wipe it. I like gear I can understand. The Weaver Equine felt lined Smart Cinch is that kind of gear. It is not a fancy cinch, and it is not a complicated one. It is the one that ended a rub I could not solve with another string cinch.
What I'd Skip
I would skip any cinch that is too short, cracked, or stiff as a board. I would skip the habit of tightening the cinch all at once before the horse has walked out. I would skip a fleece cover that bunches under the belly just to avoid buying the right cinch. And I would skip blaming the horse for a sore back. If Sarge had come up sore over the loin or flinched at the saddle, I would have called a saddle fitter before I bought another piece of tack. A cinch rub behind the elbow is one thing. A horse that is sore under the saddle is a different conversation, and it needs a fitter or a vet.
The rub behind Sarge's left elbow healed in about three weeks of rest, and it has not come back in two and a half years of regular riding.
The cinch I would buy again for a sensitive horse
If your horse has a rub behind the elbow and the saddle fit has been checked, the Weaver Equine Felt Lined Smart Cinch is worth a look. Measure your horse, brush the felt after each ride, and give the rub time to heal before you judge the change.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →